Home > Case Studies > DWI > Can a Driver Refuse a Field Sobriety Test in New York?

Can a Driver Refuse a Field Sobriety Test in New York?

by | Jan 25, 2023

In a case where a driver is suspected of operating their vehicle under the influence of alcohol, a preliminary breath test isn’t the only test a police officer might ask to administer. Part of the arrest process may include conducting field sobriety tests. These types of tests are designed to assess a driver’s balance, coordination, and reflexes. They are typically used to help law enforcement establish probable cause before making a DWI arrest.  

Types of Field Sobriety Tests

Field sobriety tests are entirely voluntary — you cannot be forced to take one if you are pulled over on suspicion of drunk driving. If you agree to the test, the police officer will provide instructions on how to perform it and look for evidence of impairment. But it’s important to understand that while officers are trained in conducting field sobriety tests, these assessments are not always accurate. There can be a number of factors that affect the reliability of a field sobriety test. 

The field sobriety tests commonly administered by law enforcement in New York include the following:

  • The Walk and Turn — With this test, the police officer will ask you to walk in a straight line, while making contact between your heel and toe. On your ninth step, you will have to pivot in a certain way. 
  • The One Leg Stand — This test requires you to stand with one leg on the ground while lifting the other a minimum of 6 inches off the ground. If you do not maintain your balance, the officer may count this against you. 
  • The Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus (HGN) — When conducting this test, the police officer will ask you to follow an object with your eyes. They will look to see whether your eye has a jerking motion.
  • Finger to Nose — In this field sobriety test, you must keep your eyes closed and use the tip of your index finger to make contact with the tip of your nose.
  • Romberg Balance Test — This test measures your balance and ability to remember the directions you were provided. You will have to stand with your feet together, hands at your side, with your head tilted back and eyes closed. You will be required to guess when 30 seconds have passed. If police notice any evidence of imbalance or failure to follow instructions, this can be used against you in a DWI case. 

Critically, there are many reasons a sober driver might fail a field sobriety test. Not only can these situations be stressful, but a driver may have a medical condition that can affect their ability to successfully perform the test. In addition, road surfaces, weather conditions, and footwear can impact the outcome of a field sobriety test. 

Are You Permitted to Refuse a Field Sobriety Test?  

A driver is under no legal obligation to participate in a field sobriety test. Unlike refusing a breath test, refusing to take a field sobriety test does not result in an automatic license suspension. New York is an “implied consent” state only for the purposes of breath tests — this rule does not extend to field sobriety tests.

Even though a driver is not legally required to submit to one of these tests, refusal to take a field sobriety test may be admissible at a DWI trial. Specifically, the prosecutor may try to argue that the refusal demonstrates a consciousness of guilt. But whether you took a field sobriety test or not, it’s crucial to be aware that they are extremely subjective. An experienced DWI defense attorney will know how to challenge the results of a field sobriety test if they were not in your favor.

Contact an Experienced New York DWI Attorney

If you have been arrested for a DWI, it’s essential to have a knowledgeable criminal defense attorney by your side to protect your rights and fight the charges against you. The DWI attorneys at D’Emilia Law offer experienced counsel and relentless representation for those who have been charged with DWIs and are committed to obtaining the best possible outcome for every client. To schedule a consultation, contact us at 1-888-DEMILIA.  

Field Sobriety Test

New York Launches “STOP-DWI Month” and “Don’t Drive High” Campaigns

New York State is notoriously tough on impaired drivers, and driving under the influence of alcohol or marijuana can result in serious legal consequences. Significantly, New York is cracking down on impaired driving with two new public awareness campaigns that were...

New York State Seeks to Implement Cannabis DWI Test

With the legalization of recreational marijuana in New York State, the New York State Department of Health is examining methodologies that can be used to detect cannabis-impaired driving. Unlike the technologies that can determine a person’s blood alcohol content in...

5 Common Myths and Misconceptions About New York DWIs

Being arrested for a DWI can be a stressful, scary, and overwhelming experience. Your liberty, reputation in the community, and professional standing are all on the line when you are facing drinking and driving charges. However, many people have various misconceptions...
Gun New York

What Does the Bruen Case Mean for Gun Owners in New York?

This past June, the Supreme Court of the United States issued a landmark decision in the case, New York State Rifle and Pistol Association v. Bruen. The Court held that New York’s “proper cause” requirement for a concealed pistol license violated the Fourteenth...
Bail Reform

Understanding New York’s Bail Reform Laws

New York’s controversial cashless bail legislation eliminated the use of cash bail for all but the most serious felonies and misdemeanors. The law, which was passed in 2019, has had a sweeping impact on the state’s criminal justice system over the last three years....
Concealed Carry

Understanding the New Concealed Carry Laws 

On September 1, 2022, a new concealed carry law went into effect in New York following the United States Supreme Court’s decision in New York State Rifle and Pistol Association v. Bruen. Holding that New York’s “proper cause” requirement violated the Second Amendment,...
DWI Cases

Use of Chemical Tests in New York DWI Cases

Chemical tests play a major role in DWI cases. Critically, there are typically three tests used in New York DWI cases to determine an individual’s blood alcohol content: blood tests, breath tests, and urine tests. While portable breath tests are commonly administered...

What’s the Difference Between a DWI and a DWAI?

Drinking and driving is a serious matter that can result in severe consequences. However, not every alcohol-related driving offense is charged as a DWI. Driving While Ability Impaired (DWAI) is a lesser charge that can be brought by prosecutors in some cases. Although...
Criminal Possession of a Firearm

What is Criminal Possession of a Firearm in New York?

Criminal possession of a firearm in New York is a serious crime. While this offense was once charged as a misdemeanor, as of March 2013, it can be charged as a class “E” felony. If you are arrested for unlawfully possessing an unregistered firearm, a conviction can...
White-Collar Crimes

New York White-Collar Crimes and Penalties

White-collar crimes, sometimes also referred to as economic crimes, are financially motivated offenses that can be committed by individuals, businesses, or professionals. These types of crimes are often classified as serious felonies in New York — and a conviction can...