Home > Case Studies > Appeals > When Can You Appeal a Criminal Case in New York?

When Can You Appeal a Criminal Case in New York?

by | Jan 14, 2024

If you’ve been convicted of a crime, you might still have the option to continue your defense in some situations. Depending on the circumstances of your case, you might be eligible to appeal the conviction or sentence to achieve a dismissal of your case, a reduction in your sentence, or another favorable outcome. However, it’s important to understand that you cannot file an appeal simply because you are unhappy with the outcome of your case. Legal grounds must exist to file an appeal — and certain procedures must be followed.                

What is an Appeal?

An appeal is a request to have a higher court review the lower court’s judgment to determine whether it is correct. They are conducted by a panel of judges and provide a criminal defendant with the opportunity to have a second court review the trial record and present arguments in an appellate brief. The state may also file its own appellate brief in response. 

If you intend to appeal your criminal conviction, it’s essential to understand that there are specific procedures and deadlines that must be followed before you can submit the appellate brief. Importantly, you only have a limited amount of time to appeal your case — you must serve a properly drafted Notice of Appeal on the prosecutor and file it within 30 days of the sentencing date. Failure to comply with the applicable deadlines and rules can result in your appeal being dismissed.    

What are the Grounds to Appeal a Criminal Conviction or Sentence?

If a legal error was made by the trial court that resulted in prejudice and affected the outcome of your case, the judgment or sentence may be appealed. Critically, errors can be made at any stage of a criminal trial — including in connection with decisions rendered during the trial, pre-trial motions, and post-trial motions. Common grounds for appealing a criminal case can include the following:

  • Incorrect jury instructions — If the judge provides the jury with the incorrect legal standard or improper instructions, they may reach a different verdict than they should have. Incorrect or incomplete jury instructions may be grounds for an appeal.  
  • Plain errors — If an error was made that was obvious and egregious, it may support an appeal. For example, a plain error may arise if the judge expressed an opinion regarding your guilt.   
  • Juror misconduct — A conviction can be appealed if jurors engaged in misconduct by talking about the case with non-jurors, considering evidence other than what was introduced at trial, deciding a case by lot rather than vote, or taking a bribe.                       
  • Prosecutorial misconduct — In the event the prosecutor engaged in misconduct by referring to evidence that the court deemed inadmissible or withheld exculpatory evidence, grounds for an appeal may exist.             
  • Sentencing errors — The law specifies the sentences that may be imposed for each crime and what factors may be considered. If the judge disregarded the rules concerning sentencing, the decision may be appealed. 
  • Ineffective assistance of trial counsel — A criminal defendant has the Constitutional right to have effective assistance of counsel. If your attorney’s conduct fell below a certain standard and deprived you of your right to counsel, you may be able to appeal the conviction on these grounds. 
  • Improper exclusion/admission of evidence — If the court makes an error in determining whether certain evidence should be admitted or excluded at trial, this may support an appeal.                                             

Additionally, decisions made by the court on pre-trial issues can be appealed. For instance, if your arrest was made in violation of your Fourth Amendment rights or you were not given a speedy trial, you may be able to appeal the court’s ruling if an error was made in deciding those issues. You might also be able to appeal your case if you were not legally competent to stand trial.     

Contact an Experienced New York Criminal Appeals Attorney

Appealing a conviction or sentence in a criminal case is complex and it’s vital to have a skillful attorney by your side who can guide you through the process. Offering aggressive advocacy and relentless representation, the criminal appeals attorneys at D’Emilia Law know how to evaluate a case to determine whether errors were made at trial — and have the experience necessary to craft a strong appeal. To schedule a consultation to learn how we can assist you with your criminal appeal, contact us at 1-888-DEMILIA.

Chemical Test

What are the Consequences of Refusing a Chemical Test?

Under New York’s Implied Consent law, all drivers agree to submit to a chemical test if they are pulled over on reasonable suspicion of drunk driving. These tests are used by law enforcement to determine the level of alcohol in the blood. While the most common...
Pre-Trial Motion

What is a Pre-Trial Motion?

If you’ve been charged with a crime, you need a solid defense. One of the tools your criminal defense attorney will use as part of your defense strategy is the filing of pre-trial motions. Depending on the facts and circumstances of your case, a pre-trial motion can...
Zero Tolerance Law

What is New York’s Zero Tolerance Law?

Being charged with drunk driving at any age is a serious criminal offense that can result in steep consequences. However, New York State law provides distinct penalties for underage drivers who have been charged with DWIs. The Zero Tolerance Law specifies a lower...
Fifth Amendment

Understanding the Protections of the Fifth Amendment

Under the United States Constitution, an individual who has been accused of a crime is protected from self-incrimination. Commonly referred to as “the right to remain silent,” the Fifth Amendment guarantees that a person cannot be compelled by the government to...
Fourth Amendment

What is the Fourth Amendment Protection Against Unreasonable Search and Seizure?

The Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution guarantees protections to individuals from unlawful search and seizure by the government. However, it’s important to understand that this right doesn’t mean you can never be searched by the police. It only extends to...
Assault Charges

Understanding Assault Charges in New York

Being charged with an assault in New York is a serious matter — and a conviction can have a wide range of consequences on your life and livelihood. From employment opportunities to finding housing, obtaining a professional license, and retaining your right to possess...
Weapons Crimes

Weapons Crimes in New York

New York has some of the strictest weapons laws in the nation. Critically, not only can being convicted of a weapon crime lead to a criminal record, but it can also result in the long-term ramifications that come with one — impacting both your daily life and...
Rights Crime

What are Your Rights if You’ve Been Charged with a Crime?

Regardless of the crime with which you’ve been charged, it’s essential to understand that you have certain rights under the U.S. Constitution and the New York State Constitution. These rights are meant to protect against arbitrary treatment by the government and...
DWI Attorney

Do You Need an Attorney for a DWI Charge?

If you’ve been charged with driving under the influence in New York, you may be wondering whether you should have the representation of an attorney. Critically, being charged with driving under the influence in New York can have a long-lasting impact on your life and...
DWI Felony

When is a DWI a Felony in New York?

A DWI can come with serious consequences, especially if you’re facing felony charges. While a first DWI is typically charged as a misdemeanor, there are certain situations in which an offense of driving under the influence can be a felony. For instance, if there are...