Home > Insights > DWI > Can the Necessity Defense Be Used in DWI Cases in New York?

Can the Necessity Defense Be Used in DWI Cases in New York?

by | Jul 11, 2023

Driving under the influence is a very serious offense in New York that requires a skillful and strategic defense. Critically, one of the defenses that may be available to those who have been charged with the offense of driving under the influence is the “necessity defense.” This defense is available in very limited cases in which an individual operated a vehicle with a Blood Alcohol Concentration (BAC) above the legal limit in an emergency situation to avoid an imminent injury. Codified under New York Penal Law § 35.05, the necessity defense is also referred to as the choice of evils doctrine.  

How is the Necessity Defense Used in DWI Cases?

To use the necessity defense in a case involving drunk driving, a driver must establish that they operated their vehicle under the influence to prevent a greater evil that was more serious than the harm that could potentially result from a DWI. Specifically, the conduct must have been necessary “to avoid an imminent public or private injury which is about to occur by reason of a situation occasioned or developed” by no fault of the defendant. The imminent injury must be so serious that “according to standards of intelligence and morality,” the urgency associated with avoiding it clearly outweighed the desirability of avoiding the injury the DWI statute seeks to prevent.  

Simply put, in order for a DWI defendant to successfully use the necessity defense, they must prove the following:

  • They had a reasonable belief that there was an actual threat
  • The situation required them to take immediate action
  • There was no realistic alternative other than driving under the influence
  • The harm caused by driving while intoxicated was not greater than harm avoided
  • They did not cause or contribute to the threat

In considering the necessity defense, a court will evaluate whether the specific circumstances of the case would justify it. Typically, the facts must show that the defendant had no alternative other than to drive while intoxicated to prevent harm to themselves or another. 

Who Has the Burden of Proof When the Necessity Defense is Asserted in a DWI?

Also known as “justification,” necessity is an affirmative defense. This means the burden of proof shifts to the defendant who must prove by a preponderance of the evidence that their conduct was necessary. This is a much lower burden of proof than the “reasonable doubt” standard that the prosecution must meet at trial.

If the evidence introduced by the defendant is found to be credible, criminal liability will be negated. The burden then shifts back to prosecution, who is required to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant’s conduct was not justified. In other words, they must disprove the defendant’s affirmative defense. However, it’s important to understand that reasonable doubt does not mean the elimination of all doubt — jurors are still permitted to have a small amount of doubt to find a defendant guilty of a criminal offense.         

Contact an Experienced New York Criminal Defense Attorney

If you have been accused of driving under the influence, it’s critical to have a knowledgeable criminal defense attorney by your side who can build a strong defense in your case. The attorneys at D’Emilia Law offer relentless representation for those who have been charged with DWIs and work to obtain the best possible outcomes in their cases. To schedule a consultation, contact us at 1-888-DEMILIA. 

New York DWI Cases
DWI Arrest

Common Mistakes to Avoid During a DWI Arrest

Being pulled over for drinking and driving can be a stressful and overwhelming experience. A DWI can not only result in monetary fines and jail time, but it can also lead to personal, professional, and financial ramifications. Critically, any mistakes you make during...
Dispensary license violation attorney

Four Important Things to Know About New York’s Marijuana Laws

As the legal landscape regarding marijuana laws continues to shift, New York became the 16th state to legalize cannabis in 2021. However, there are still certain restrictions in place and it’s important to understand these laws to avoid incurring criminal penalties....
Chemical Test

What are the Consequences of Refusing a Chemical Test?

Under New York’s Implied Consent law, all drivers agree to submit to a chemical test if they are pulled over on reasonable suspicion of drunk driving. These tests are used by law enforcement to determine the level of alcohol in the blood. While the most common...
Pre-Trial Motion

What is a Pre-Trial Motion?

If you’ve been charged with a crime, you need a solid defense. One of the tools your criminal defense attorney will use as part of your defense strategy is the filing of pre-trial motions. Depending on the facts and circumstances of your case, a pre-trial motion can...
Zero Tolerance Law

What is New York’s Zero Tolerance Law?

Being charged with drunk driving at any age is a serious criminal offense that can result in steep consequences. However, New York State law provides distinct penalties for underage drivers who have been charged with DWIs. The Zero Tolerance Law specifies a lower...

When Can You Appeal a Criminal Case in New York?

If you’ve been convicted of a crime, you might still have the option to continue your defense in some situations. Depending on the circumstances of your case, you might be eligible to appeal the conviction or sentence to achieve a dismissal of your case, a reduction...
Fifth Amendment

Understanding the Protections of the Fifth Amendment

Under the United States Constitution, an individual who has been accused of a crime is protected from self-incrimination. Commonly referred to as “the right to remain silent,” the Fifth Amendment guarantees that a person cannot be compelled by the government to...
Fourth Amendment

What is the Fourth Amendment Protection Against Unreasonable Search and Seizure?

The Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution guarantees protections to individuals from unlawful search and seizure by the government. However, it’s important to understand that this right doesn’t mean you can never be searched by the police. It only extends to...
Assault Charges

Understanding Assault Charges in New York

Being charged with an assault in New York is a serious matter — and a conviction can have a wide range of consequences on your life and livelihood. From employment opportunities to finding housing, obtaining a professional license, and retaining your right to possess...
Weapons Crimes

Weapons Crimes in New York

New York has some of the strictest weapons laws in the nation. Critically, not only can being convicted of a weapon crime lead to a criminal record, but it can also result in the long-term ramifications that come with one — impacting both your daily life and...