Home > Legal Tips > Is Self-Defense a Justification in New York?

Is Self-Defense a Justification in New York?

by | Feb 16, 2023

New York law permits the use of self-defense, also referred to as “justification,” in limited situations. Notably, it is a defense that may be asserted in specific cases where the defendant’s use of physical force would otherwise constitute a criminal act. Cases involving self-defense can be extremely complex — but when justification exists, a defendant may be able to avoid criminal prosecution.  

What Constitutes Self-Defense?

Article 35 of the New York Penal Law outlines when an individual is justified in using physical force in self-defense, or in the defense of others. Under the statute, a person can use the amount of physical force they reasonably believe is necessary to defend themselves or others from what they reasonably believe to be the illegal imminent use of force or the illegal use of force. 

There are only certain circumstances under which a person can assert the justification of self-defense in cases involving deadly force. Since New York imposes a duty to retreat, it is only permissible to use deadly physical force when there is no other option. 

Situations where deadly force can be used in self-defense include circumstances involving: 

  • Kidnapping
  • Forcible rape
  • Robbery
  • Arson
  • Burglary

Importantly, you cannot use the justification of self-defense if you were the person who started the fight — unless you withdrew from it and communicated your withdrawal. The defense of justification will also fail if you were the initial aggressor. In other words, if you provoked the other person to attack with the intent to cause physical injury to them, the self-defense justification may not apply. 

Understanding New York’s Castle Doctrine and the Duty to Retreat

When it comes to self-defense, New York law recognizes both a “duty to retreat” and the “castle doctrine.” It’s important to understand the difference between these two concepts and how they apply in scenarios involving the use of deadly force. 

The duty to retreat means that a person has an obligation to take reasonable steps to mitigate the risk of harm before they can use deadly force. However, the duty to retreat is fact specific and requires actual knowledge of a safe retreat. For instance, if someone pulls out a firearm and shoots it in your direction, you might be justified in asserting deadly force in order to protect yourself — unless you knew of a way in which you could retreat to complete safety. 

Notably, there is no duty to retreat inside one’s home under New York law. Under the castle doctrine, an individual is permitted to use deadly force to defend themselves and their family inside their home against an intruder. In these cases, you do not have to retreat to a different room — the law allows you to stand your ground. 

Contact an Experienced New York Criminal Defense Attorney   

If you have been charged with a crime for acting in self-defense, it’s vital to have an experienced criminal defense attorney on your side who can fight for your rights. The attorneys at D’Emilia Law offer skillful counsel and committed representation for those who have been charged with a crime for acting in defense of themselves or others and work relentlessly to obtain the best possible outcome for every client. To schedule a consultation, contact us at 1-888-DEMILIA. 

Impaired Driver Program

What is the New York State Impaired Driver Program?

A consequence of a DWI conviction in New York can be license suspension or revocation. Losing your license, even temporarily, can have a substantial impact on your life and livelihood. However, if you qualify for the Impaired Driver Program — formerly known as the...
DWI Attorney

5 Common Legal Defenses to DWIs in New York

A DWI is a serious criminal offense in New York that can come with life-changing penalties. If you’ve been charged with driving while under the influence of alcohol, it’s crucial to have an experienced DWI attorney who can fight the charges on your behalf. A skilled...

Can You Challenge the Results of a Breathalyzer Test?

If you’ve been pulled over on the suspicion that you were driving under the influence of alcohol, the police will likely ask you to take a breathalyzer test to determine your blood alcohol concentration (BAC). Under New York’s implied consent laws, a driver is...
Field Sobriety Test

Can a Driver Refuse a Field Sobriety Test in New York?

In a case where a driver is suspected of operating their vehicle under the influence of alcohol, a preliminary breath test isn’t the only test a police officer might ask to administer. Part of the arrest process may include conducting field sobriety tests. These types...

New York Launches “STOP-DWI Month” and “Don’t Drive High” Campaigns

New York State is notoriously tough on impaired drivers, and driving under the influence of alcohol or marijuana can result in serious legal consequences. Significantly, New York is cracking down on impaired driving with two new public awareness campaigns that were...

New York State Seeks to Implement Cannabis DWI Test

With the legalization of recreational marijuana in New York State, the New York State Department of Health is examining methodologies that can be used to detect cannabis-impaired driving. Unlike the technologies that can determine a person’s blood alcohol content in...

5 Common Myths and Misconceptions About New York DWIs

Being arrested for a DWI can be a stressful, scary, and overwhelming experience. Your liberty, reputation in the community, and professional standing are all on the line when you are facing drinking and driving charges. However, many people have various misconceptions...
Gun New York

What Does the Bruen Case Mean for Gun Owners in New York?

This past June, the Supreme Court of the United States issued a landmark decision in the case, New York State Rifle and Pistol Association v. Bruen. The Court held that New York’s “proper cause” requirement for a concealed pistol license violated the Fourteenth...
Bail Reform

Understanding New York’s Bail Reform Laws

New York’s controversial cashless bail legislation eliminated the use of cash bail for all but the most serious felonies and misdemeanors. The law, which was passed in 2019, has had a sweeping impact on the state’s criminal justice system over the last three years....
Concealed Carry

Understanding the New Concealed Carry Laws 

On September 1, 2022, a new concealed carry law went into effect in New York following the United States Supreme Court’s decision in New York State Rifle and Pistol Association v. Bruen. Holding that New York’s “proper cause” requirement violated the Second Amendment,...