Home > Criminal Defense > Should a Defendant Testify at Trial?

Should a Defendant Testify at Trial?

by | Feb 4, 2022

A big question for many criminal defendants is whether they should take the witness stand. Particularly when the defendant is innocent, they often feel compelled to testify in order to tell the jury that they didn’t commit the crime with which they’ve been charged. But it’s not quite so simple. In some situations, testifying can work to a defendant’s advantage — in others, it can destroy their case.
Significantly, testifying at trial is a strategic decision that must be carefully considered. An attorney can best advise their client regarding the potential pros and cons of testifying based on the facts and circumstances of their specific case. More often than not, a criminal defense attorney will recommend that their client remain silent.      

The Protections of the Fifth Amendment

In a criminal case, a defendant has the right to testify at trial — but they are not required to do so. The Fifth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution protects a defendant from self-incrimination — this includes the right not to testify at trial or respond to any questions posed by the prosecution or the judge. However, if a defendant opts to take the witness stand, their right to remain silent is considered to be waived.     
It’s important to understand that whether a defendant testifies or not, it can’t be held against them. They are still presumed to be innocent unless the prosecution proves their case beyond a reasonable doubt — and the defendant is found guilty by a jury of their peers.

Deciding Whether to Testify at Trial  

The decision of whether to testify ultimately remains with the defendant. But it’s crucial for a defendant to understand that no matter how much they think that they may be able to convince a jury of their innocence, the questions the prosecution may pose can be exceptionally difficult and confusing. One misstep is all it can take to make a defendant who is innocent appear to be guilty.   
Three important factors that should be considered when determining whether a defendant should testify include the following:

  • Whether the defendant has a prior criminal record — Although a prior criminal record is otherwise not admissible, it can come in if the prosecutor seeks to impeach the defendant while they are testifying.
  • The defendant’s demeanor — The jury will be watching the defendant’s demeanor very closely as they testify. Specifically, they will be evaluating whether the defendant is likable and credible or cold and evasive.
  • Whether the defendant performs well under stress — Testifying can be stressful, emotional, and overwhelming. Some people cannot perform well under such circumstances and become agitated or nervous. A jury may wrongfully interpret this behavior as a sign of the defendant’s guilt.

Testifying on the stand can humanize a defendant if the testimony is delivered honestly and credibly. However, it’s crucial to consider how much value it would bring to the case. Although a defendant’s testimony can sometimes win over the jury, more often than not, it serves to benefit the prosecution.

Contact an Experienced New York City Criminal Defense Attorney

Testifying at trial is a critical decision that should only be made after consulting with a knowledgeable criminal defense attorney. If you’ve been accused of a crime, it’s essential to have a skilled attorney who can protect your rights every step of the way. The criminal defense attorneys at D’Emilia Law offer high-quality legal services and dedicated counsel to those who have been charged with a wide variety of crimes in New York — and strive to obtain the most favorable outcomes in their cases. To schedule a consultation, contact us at 1-888-DEMILIA.    

Testify at Trial
Criminal Case

What is a Bench Trial in a Criminal Case?

Most people are familiar with jury trials and know that a defendant has the Constitutional right to be tried by a jury of their peers in a serious criminal case. But a jury trial isn’t always the only option. If you’ve been charged with a felony or certain...
Pre-Trial Motion

What is a Pre-Trial Motion?

If you’ve been charged with a crime, you need a solid defense. One of the tools your criminal defense attorney will use as part of your defense strategy is the filing of pre-trial motions. Depending on the facts and circumstances of your case, a pre-trial motion can...
Zero Tolerance Law

What is New York’s Zero Tolerance Law?

Being charged with drunk driving at any age is a serious criminal offense that can result in steep consequences. However, New York State law provides distinct penalties for underage drivers who have been charged with DWIs. The Zero Tolerance Law specifies a lower...

When Can You Appeal a Criminal Case in New York?

If you’ve been convicted of a crime, you might still have the option to continue your defense in some situations. Depending on the circumstances of your case, you might be eligible to appeal the conviction or sentence to achieve a dismissal of your case, a reduction...
Fifth Amendment

Understanding the Protections of the Fifth Amendment

Under the United States Constitution, an individual who has been accused of a crime is protected from self-incrimination. Commonly referred to as “the right to remain silent,” the Fifth Amendment guarantees that a person cannot be compelled by the government to...
Fourth Amendment

What is the Fourth Amendment Protection Against Unreasonable Search and Seizure?

The Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution guarantees protections to individuals from unlawful search and seizure by the government. However, it’s important to understand that this right doesn’t mean you can never be searched by the police. It only extends to...
DWI Felony

When is a DWI a Felony in New York?

A DWI can come with serious consequences, especially if you’re facing felony charges. While a first DWI is typically charged as a misdemeanor, there are certain situations in which an offense of driving under the influence can be a felony. For instance, if there are...
Drug Treatment Court

What is Drug Treatment Court — and is it an Option in My Case?

If you were arrested for a non-violent drug crime, you may be eligible for drug treatment court. This is a voluntary alternative to the regular court process that allows non-violent, drug-addicted offenders to enter into a treatment program, and potentially avoid...
Search Warrant

What is a Search Warrant? 

Most people are aware that the police are usually prohibited from searching a premises or person without a warrant under the Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. A search warrant is a court order issued for the purpose of authorizing law enforcement to conduct a...
Subway Self-Defense

NYC Subway Incident Raises Complex Legal Questions Regarding Self-Defense

The recent New York City subway incident that resulted in the death of Jordan Neely made headlines throughout the nation. While there are still many facts that are not yet known, and various issues that will need to be determined at trial, the case raises many...